Kobie
Proper addict
Xena, warrior princess
Posts: 1,027
|
Post by Kobie on Nov 27, 2006 21:13:28 GMT 1
Daniela, Excellent is given to a dog who approch the weimaraner standard very well ! Very good is given to a dog who is nice, but with a (medium) fault in the standard, and good is actually almost never given to a dog. This mark is for dogs who has big faults conserning the standard ! The ones who got "good" weren't that good handled, but I don't think it's a breed fault !!!!  It's wrong to give a nice dog a lower mark, just because he isn't good handled !!!! Should ask to the ones who saw them in the ring, but I hardly see marks "good".... Of course, if a judge give all excellents, you can believe the judge wants to be "popular". Way of living for a judge  And this isn't good as well..... Who will say what's the best .... |
|
efica
Intermediate
Kika Aruba Imperium Star
Posts: 306
|
Post by efica on Nov 27, 2006 21:52:41 GMT 1
Congratulations to everyone and especially to Paulina and Oska  I've met Oska just a week ago when we went to Poland for our Kika. Oska is a great dog-beautiful and very sweet character!!! |
|
|
|
Post by daniela on Nov 27, 2006 21:53:22 GMT 1
Daniela, Excellent is given to a dog who approch the weimaraner standard very well ! Very good is given to a dog who is nice, but with a (medium) fault in the standard, and good is actually almost never given to a dog. This mark is for dogs who has big faults conserning the standard ! The ones who got "good" weren't that good handled, but I don't think it's a breed fault !!!! It's wrong to give a nice dog a lower mark, just because he isn't good handled !!!! Should ask to the ones who saw them in the ring, but I hardly see marks "good".... Of course, if a judge give all excellents, you can believe the judge wants to be "popular". Way of living for a judge And this isn't good as well..... Who will say what's the best .... Thanks Kobie. Does the FCI provide the judges with guidelines as to what the grades mean? |
|
|
|
Post by Jaeger on Nov 27, 2006 21:55:46 GMT 1
The grades Excellent, Very Good, Good and Moderate are common in the Judging system from the FCI, which is used almost all over the world by the judges. There are only a few countries left with a different system.
And the judge did make another mistake. With a qualification "Good", you are not allowed to place the doggs/bitches. Don't think he was a breed specialist. May be an allrounder.
|
|
Kobie
Proper addict
Xena, warrior princess
Posts: 1,027
|
Post by Kobie on Nov 28, 2006 7:05:09 GMT 1
And the judge did make another mistake. With a qualification "Good", you are not allowed to place the doggs/bitches. Don't think he was a breed specialist. May be an allrounder. Oh yes, that's true... I didn't even mentioned it ! |
|
|
|
Post by marjolein on Nov 28, 2006 8:33:25 GMT 1
I heard another weird story about the judge who was judging the Drentsch Partridge dogs. He gave 8 dogs in a class an excellent. He then send the dogs away, apart from the 4 best dogs of that class. But, he made a little mistake and the dog that he'd placed 4th, turned out to have an excellent..... He then decided to change the very good to and excellent so he could keep his fourth place. How weird.....
|
|
|
|
Post by Jurate on Nov 28, 2006 8:46:32 GMT 1
Very nice photos and a really weird judgind...  |
|
|
|
Post by bromhund on Nov 28, 2006 10:46:38 GMT 1
Well done to all  |
|
|
|
Post by cummel on Nov 28, 2006 18:55:52 GMT 1
it was very nice to meet you people from the forum and beautiful dogs!!!
|
|
